Thursday, November 1, 2012
Tempting Jesus!
Tuesday, October 2, 2012
Was Jesus Married?
Monday, September 26, 2011
Shared from the blog www.extendbiblestudy.blogspot.com
The genealogy of Jesus in Luke 3:23ff
This will be for those who were not present and also a way to let those present (and absent) to add their comments to the discussion. Feel free to respond.
Some of our observations.
1. Matthew opens his gospel with the genealogy of Jesus. Matthew 1:1 "An account of the genealogy of Jesus the Messiah, the son of David, the son of Abraham." (Mat 1:1 NRS) With clarity, he establishes Jesus link to Messianic kingship (the Davidic Covenant) and Israel's covenant as a people (the Abrahamic covenant). Jesus link to the Jewish covenant and his fulfillment of the promises they hold is a theme throughout Matthew's gospel.
The question asked the previous week: WHY DID LUKE WAIT TO GIVE THE GENEALOGY OF JESUS IN COMPARISON TO MATTHEW?
Of course, the simple and obvious answer is that Luke acknowledges in Luke 1:1-3 that, while other orderly accounts have been written, after careful consideration (study?), he too will write an orderly account.
"Since many have undertaken to set down an orderly account of the events that have been fulfilled among us, 2 just as they were handed on to us by those who from the beginning were eyewitnesses and servants of the word, 3 I too decided, after investigating everything carefully from the very first, to write an orderly account for you, most excellent Theophilus," (Luk 1:1-3 NRS)
From this, we may assume that the order of Luke's account is significant. The placement of the genealogy is no mere afterthought.
Consider:
Luke 1:4 opens the story of the birth and role of the messenger sent to prepare the way. In Jewish tradition, this was Elijah, the great prophet. John is born of the high priestly lineage as both his parents are descendants of the Aaronic line of priests. The name of the messenger, while not Elijah, embodies the message for the name John, means "the grace of the Lord." What a fitting name. At the close of every Seder meal (Passover Meal), the cup of Elijah or the cup of Redemption, is poured but left untouched to wait for the Messiah. Indeed, this hope is found in the "mercy of God."
In Luke, every key character in these opening chapters recognizes that Jesus birth is the birth of the Messiah. From Elizabeth and Mary to Joseph and the Shepherds, they know. The events of Luke 2 further intensify the drama of this remarkable birth as a boy in the temple surprises the elders with his questions.
As the narrative continues with John the Baptizer's ministry, it becomes even more climactic. John declares:
As the people were filled with expectation, and all were questioning in their hearts concerning John, whether he might be the Messiah, 16 John answered all of them by saying, "I baptize you with water; but one who is more powerful than I is coming; I am not worthy to untie the thong of his sandals. He will baptize you with the Holy Spirit and fire 17 His winnowing fork is in his hand, to clear his threshing floor and to gather the wheat into his granary; but the chaff he will burn with unquenchable fire."
(Luk 3:15-17 NRS)
Following his account of John's imprisonment, Luke returns to the event of Jesus baptism as the stage is being set. At the baptism, a heavenly voice speaks: "and the Holy Spirit descended upon him in bodily form like a dove. And a voice came from heaven, "You are my Son, the Beloved; with you I am well pleased." (Luk 3:22 NRS)
God's son! It is time for the genealogy.
While Matthew begins with Abraham and David, declaring the covenant, Luke begins with Joseph, who we already know from Luke, is not the real father of Jesus. Luke moves through the generations back to David, to Abraham and continues all the way to Adam (of the earth). Luke 3:38b "... Adam, son of God."
Our lives come from God, the creator. Our redemption, our place within the family of God, comes in a son, who like Adam, was born through the mystery and power of the Creator's love. This second Adam has something new to give, something more. Luke does not want us to miss it. This is God at work within creation. The Lord of Sabbath is here. God has personally intervened and come to save us.
Wow!
Keep reading. It just gets better.
Monday, August 22, 2011
Did Jesus really call that woman a dog?
A friend of mine recently heard a sermon on Matthew 15:21-28 from another pastor.
In Matthew's retelling of the story, Jesus calls the Canaanite woman a dog. In some ways, the sermon's exegesis left him troubled. I just couldn’t envision Christ doing it out of frustration (seems very near to sin) or that he was taught anything by an earthly being.
Honestly, this has been an ongoing dialogue for me in understanding the humanity of Jesus. And, I have heard it said: "Historically, the church has struggled far more with the humanity of Jesus than we have with the divinity of Jesus."
Here is a brief account of some of my reflection on the story:
Some people take the position (an interpretation) that Jesus knew what he was doing and was putting the woman to the test to see how she would respond. My problem with this is that I do not see Jesus doing this. The Pharisees often put Jesus to the test. Jesus challenged people to do things that they might otherwise choose not to do; however, he never appears to put them to the test. In truth, he teaches us to pray, "Lead us not into temptation…" which can also be translated, "Lead us not into the time of testing…" Even then, the testing comes from life and life circumstances rather than God recalling in Hebrews 12 that we are told to consider difficulties as God's discipline.
In Jesus, the Son of God, we see God's mercy and love. And, after Jesus, God gives the judgment over to Jesus, who, as Paul notes in Romans, "died for us and sits at God's right hand and prays for us." In relation to this passage, it is Jesus who leads us in the right paths as the good shepherd leads the sheep.
So, the question, what's going on in this passage that would result in Jesus calling this woman a dog? The Bible makes it clear that Jesus came as a human being, lived as a human being, died as a human being and faced life's trials as a human. The New Testament teaches us that Jesus emptied himself of his divinity so that he could become like us. This means that he had to "grow in wisdom and stature" as every human being. It means that he learned "obedience through what he suffered" (Hebrews) even though he was God's son.
The implication in this is that Jesus would "come to know" his mission through the scripture, his tradition and in his relationship with the Father of all. Or, to put it into plain terms: Jesus would "come to know" with tools that are available to every human being.
Assuming that Jesus was fully human, as the scripture teaches and that he would learn in the way of humans, I believe that this story was a turning point (again, as I understand the scripture).
God works in mysterious ways. God speaks to his people. And certainly, the relationship of the Son, while the same as ours, is unique at the same time. I expect that one of the most important questions is: How does God speak to us? How do we learn? All of us know that people learn in many different ways. And, in reality, most of us do not learn simply by study or even prayer. We learn in the experiences of life. And, sometimes, God speaks to us through the stranger or even through those who may come from very different places. Was this true for Jesus as well?
My friends observation about how Jesus response might be "very close to sin" is a question that cannot be ignored. This question requires that we examine again a definition of sin in the Bible. How do we define sin? In Romans, Paul gives a Jewish explanation. Paul explains that before the "law" (the Torah), sin did not exist. He goes on to say that the Torah was given so that we might recognize sin. In short: When we are enlightened by God, if we choose to make the light darkness, it is sin (my interpretation). This means for Paul that before the law was given to the people, sin did not exist -- although he says that there is a law given to every person that is literally written on our hearts -- but these laws are broad and non-specific about human actions -- rather they are the laws of the created world that allow us to know there is a God and to come to know this God. The specific law Paul speaks about is the Torah that God gave to Moses for the chosen people. About this he says that it was given to show us that we were sinners but it could not save us or make us righteousness (holy). The only thing he writes that can make us righteous is the righteousness of Christ.
Which brings us to your issue. If we follow some of this, does it mean that Jesus sinned? No. The difference between Jesus and us is that when the light comes on for Jesus, he never makes the light darkness. For this reason, we say with confidence, he was without sin. Consider what the gospel of John says about the light: the light (Christ) has come into the world but people preferred darkness to that light.
Someone might ask the question, did Jesus inherit the original sin from Adam if he was fully human? It depends on how we define original sin. For me, what we inherit from Adam is death. As in Adam, all die. It is this reality that Jesus comes to defeat -- in the flesh he will defeat death by dying.
Ok, this is deep. Back up. Look one more time at the story of Matthew 15.
What is the meaning of the story:
1. Jesus is seeking to be alone with his disciples and away from the constant probing of the scribes and Pharisees who argue about non-issues.
2. He goes to a non-Jewish region.
3. A non-Jewish woman approaches him with a Jewish plea (as if she is a Jew), "Son of David, help me."
4. He ignores her (if he is testing someone, it is his disciples).
5. The disciples say send her away.
6. She persists.
7. He reminds her that the "Son of David" (a messiah term) would be sent to the lost sheep of the house of Israel -- save the Jews and they will save the world (Exodus 19 tells us that Israel is chosen to be a nation of priests and a light to the nations or gentiles)
8. She persists.
9. It is not right, Jesus says, to give bread prepared for children, to their dogs.* (Reminding her that she is not a Jew?). Perhaps this means, "Woman if you know about the Messiah, you will know this."
*As a Jew, you would expect Jesus to respond in this manner. What surprised everyone, was the woman's response.
10. The woman surprises all, even Jesus, with a declaration of faith that is bathed in humility. "Even the dogs eat the crumbs from their master's table." It is a statement that acknowledges the scripture (Salvation is from the Jews) and opens Jesus to the dreadful reality that will come. To be savior of the Jews, he must also be savior of the world and die a terrible death at the hands of some of the very people he came to save.
11. The question then comes, Did God use this woman to reveal this truth to Jesus? The transfiguration that takes place in chapter 17 of Matthew seems to put this forward. As Jesus tells his disciples that he must die, they reject it. In the transfiguration, God speaks to Peter, James and John and tells them: "This is my Son, the beloved. Listen to him." (LISTEN TO HIM). Could this also be affirmation for Jesus that he is on the right path. After this, Jesus steps beyond the hesitancy of his disciples and walks resolutely to Jerusalem. Even so, he must go through Gethsemane where he prays, Father if it is possible, let this cup pass from me. But if not, not my will, they will be done.
There is one other intermediate event worth noting that comes after the encounter with the woman: The second miracle of the loaves and fishes occurs after the encounter. And this time, seven (for the seven most mentioned Gentile nations?) baskets of bread are left over -- does this mean that the crowd is most likely all Gentile? Previously, there were twelve baskets left over for the 12 Tribes of Israel. Enough bread for Israel. Enough for the World.
Now the real question: What does this mean for us that Jesus might have experienced life as we do? Does it make Jesus less? Certainly not. It means that Jesus overcame the weakness of the flesh so that he could truly defeat sin in the flesh. If he overcame sin as God, we could not follow him. He overcame sin in his humanity. However, this does mean that he limited himself to knowing God's will in the same way that you and I may know the will of God. This is why he could entrust the gospel message to human beings.
If we pursue this, it can give us confidence to ask, seek and knock as Jesus taught us, so that we might also come to know God's will. Can we learn to tap into the same power that Jesus found through prayer, the support of the scripture, in learning to hear the voice of God and through knowing that God still send his messengers to watch over us (remember how the angels ministered to Jesus at times) in critical moments?
I offer this as dialogue as one who also seeks. Please feel free to raise issues and respond.
Sam
Saturday, May 7, 2011
REFLECTIONS ON THE HUMANITY OF JESUS
In 1983, I started doctoral work at Emory University Candler School of Theology. In my second year of course work as a part-time student, I took Professor Carol Newsom’s class on Images of God in the Old Testament. Turning in a paper that I felt was particularly well done, her response took be aback. “These are nice thoughts,” she said. As she handed me the paper, she went on, “but, it has little to do with the text.”
Embarrassed and shocked, I took it back with the intention of teaching her a few things about the book of Exodus. Seven years later, I was still in the wilderness of the Exodus. As I examined my approach to scripture, it soon became apparent. Carol was right. Over the years, I relied on my knowledge of the text from the past and used that knowledge again and again. As for the text, I looked up the passages that would reinforce whatever was the thesis of the sermon or lesson -- or in the case of Dr. Newsom, my paper.
Please understand. The paper was well done. Well thought out. Well presented. That was not the issue. The issue was and is the text of scripture. What does the text say? I am still on this journey with the sacred text and with God. It is this journey that leads me to the most difficult challenge of life -- seeking the truth that sets us free.
For a moment before you continue, let me provoke you to examine your own approach to the scripture. Here is a statement for your reflection:Many people agree or disagree with what they have learned about the Bible from others while never examining the text of scripture themselves. Or, this one: Many people know that others tell them about the scripture but little about the text themselves.
REFLECTIONS ON THE HUMANITY OF JESUS AND HUMANITY IN GENERAL
A child arrives as a visitor from an ocean of emptiness. The emptiness is not a bad world, merely unformed, uncharted, and unknown. Like a wanderer, suffering the pain of amnesia, knowing only the most basic of hungers and thirsts, weak and helpless, totally dependent upon those who also struggle, the child enters the world. Look beyond the repository of human possibilities and beyond the basics of human need and a child is an empty book awaiting the authoring pen of life and it's myriad experiences which shape and form the void. In the beginning, the unordered chaos awaited the hovering Spirit for it's shape and form. The child also waits.
Now the earth was [ Or possibly became ] formless and empty, darkness was over the surface of the deep, and the Spirit of God was hovering over the waters. Genesis 1:2
There is poetry in the birth of a child. Each civilization possesses birthing rituals. Life sustains life. In most societies, births are anticipated with joy and wondrous expectation. The birth of Jesus was such an anticipated birth. Even when we subtract the wonder of angels, shepherds and eastern Kings, the simple wonder of a child born to parents who are full of dreams for the child cannot be ignored. And “she gave birth to her firstborn son and wrapped him in bands of cloth, and laid him in a manger, because there was no place for them in the [room]”, is descriptive of an astonishing moment for husband and wife. For Mary and Joseph, the arrival of shepherds, testifying about visions of angels, could have reaffirmed their faith in God's providential promises and reaffirmed their own dreams and visions about Jesus. Yet, for the child, the night was only filled with hunger and thirst, cold and warmth. The star that led eastern kings was as invisible to the child as the mother hen is invisible to chicks who have yet to break forth from the cocoon of an egg.
We cannot hurry Jesus, from babe in a manager to a fully self-differentiating human being apart from the normal processes of humanity unless, of course, Jesus is not fully human.
Traditional Christianity presents Jesus as Savior and Lord titles he received as a result of his committed act of obedience to God through the cross and the resurrection.
Did Jesus know from the beginning who he was and what he was sent to do? It is our contention that Jesus came to know in the manner of all human beings. Certainly, Jesus is an extraordinary person and yet, at the same time, he is limited by the humanity his birth assumes. Traditional theologians call this kinosis or self-emptying. Leaving the glory of eternity, Jesus entered this world with all the limitations of humanity. Whatever the explanation, the reality is the same. Jesus is a human being with all the struggles, difficulties and limitations that attend humanity.
Throughout history, certain individuals have achieved extraordinary accomplishments in science, the arts, military tactics and many other human endeavors that were out of what we call ordinary reach. Jesus accomplishments were in the realm of the spiritual. They were extraordinary. His teachings, his life, his personal spiritual development have guided believers for nearly twenty centuries. A greater spiritual teacher and example cannot be found. In this sense, then, is Jesus a spiritual Beethoven or Mozart? Or, is Jesus the kind of example that we may aspire too?
Jesus told his disciples, Greater works than these, you will do. (John 14:12) So many times, I have asked myself, Is such spiritual awareness available to all of us. Can we come to know the will of God as Jesus did with such depth and clarity? Is it possible?
The superficial side of me wants to recoil from any suggestion that we, as followers of God, could achieve a depth of spirituality that even approaches that of Jesus. The possibility, however, is also intriguing and compelling.
How did Jesus come to know the will and purpose of God for his life so clearly? By what means did he come to such extraordinary knowledge about himself and his world?
This discussion assumes a manifest destiny for human beings. This is not a cheap view of predestination1 that assumes human beings are somehow preprogrammed before birth. It is, however, dependent upon a knowledge of Torah and the relation of humanity to God and, the providence of God. This discussion will follow in the next chapter.
For now, two assumptions are made. First, every human may participate in Sabbath, discovering the presence of God in creation; and, second, God calls, determines, sovereignly chooses, certain human beings for significant tasks to further accomplish God's will.
The first assumption, every human may participate in Sabbath, does not mean discovering God as a part of creation. The biblical account clearly places the creator God as holy other and thus apart from creation. God's participation in creation is a willful act, on the part of God, described as Sabbath rest in the scripture. When the six days of creation are over, God enters into creation in Sabbath rest. For Christians, the climax of this perspective, the eternal God entering the temporal world, is Jesus Christ. Prior to Jesus, the humiliation of God as Jürgen Moltmann calls it, when God enters the world to interact with specific humans, happens sporadically and less clearly until Jesus. Hear again the promise to Israel: I will be your God; you will be my people; I will bring you into my rest.
As you read the following scripture, consider the cloud and pillar of fire that follows the Hebrews in the wilderness, the messengers appearing to Abraham, Moses on the mountain, and so much more.
Lev 11:45 = For I am the LORD who brought you up from the land of Egypt, to be your God; you shall be holy, for I am holy.
Num 15:40-41 = So you shall remember and do all my commandments, and you shall be holy to your God. I am the LORD your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt, to be your God: I am the LORD your God.
Exo 33:14 = The LORD replied, "My Presence will go with you, and I will give you rest."
Exo 16:23 = He said to them, "This is what the LORD commanded: 'Tomorrow is to be a day of rest, a holy Sabbath to the LORD. So bake what you want to bake and boil what you want to boil. Save whatever is left and keep it until morning.'"
In Sabbath is found the promise and the hope of fulfillment for God's clear presence within creation.
The possibility of encountering God is more than acknowledging that the heavens are telling the glory of God,.... The knowing promised by the scriptures strikes at the heart of all personal relationships. In fact (check it out), the word for rest and Sabbath have the same root. Such relationships with God result in Noah's call to ship building, Abrahams urge to travel, Moses interest in spontaneous combustion and David's music. Such ordinary activities take on profound consequences when they result from a relationship with the Almighty.
Second, God calls, determines, sovereignly chooses, certain human beings for certain significant tasks to further accomplish God's will. Human beings possess the single purpose of making the glory of God known throughout the earth. We will discuss this in future blogs. However, for now, let's ask, "What was Jesus certain, significant task? "
WHAT WAS JESUS SIGNIFICANT TASK?
Jesus came to reconcile the created world with God. According to the Gospels, such reconciliation could only be accomplished by a gift from God called grace. This gift accomplished what the revelation of scripture pointed toward but could not achieve alone. Human beings, created in the image and likeness of God, created a little lower than the angels, forgot. We lost the knowledge as if we had never possessed it. The precept was still present. The example, non-existent. Such knowledge Søren Kierkegaard alluded to as knowledge so completely forgotten that humanity could not remember it without help from beyond.
I am a great admirer of SK. And, in most cases resonate with his assessment of time and space. In this one particular concept, however, I believe that he is both right and wrong. The memory of that knowledge (humanity created in the image of God), came from beyond, from the eternal who dared to enter time, manifest in a blood and guts human being named Jesus. The problem: to be fully human, Jesus had to dissociate himself from such knowledge and become like the rest of us people who live and breathe; people subject to warts, colds, bad attitudes and fits of inappropriate verbiage. Theologically speaking, Jesus gave up (forgot) precisely what he came to help us remember. And that paradox is the reason for this exercise in thought.
HOW DID JESUS COME TO KNOW THE WILL OF GOD?
Often we speak of Jesus as if he always was what he became. Yet, the New Testament Book of Hebrews states:
Although he was a son, he learned obedience from what he suffered and, once made perfect, he became the source of eternal salvation for all who obey him....Heb 5:8-9
Because he himself suffered when he was tempted, he is able to help those who are being tempted. Heb 2:18
Note that Hebrews 5:8-9 falls on the heels of the two edged sword passage.
For the word of God is living and active. Sharper than any double-edged sword, it penetrates even to dividing soul and spirit, joints and marrow; it judges the thoughts and attitudes of the heart. Heb 4:12
Dividing the attitudes of the heart? If Jesus were indeed human, subject to bad attitudes, nasal drip and other human maladies, how did he grow beyond them? Or, how could Jesus be called sinless? (You were waiting for that one, right?)
For we do not have a high priest who is unable to sympathize with our weaknesses, but we have one who has been tempted in every way, just as we areyet was without sin. Heb 4:15
Consider the New Testament understanding of sin presented in Romans. Also, remember that Paul is firmly rooted in the Torah, the prophets and the writing of the Hebrew text. Paul wrote to the Romans:
What shall we say, then? Is the law sin? Certainly not! Indeed I would not have known what sin was except through the law. For I would not have known what coveting really was if the law had not said, Do not covet. [ Exodus 20:17; Deut. 5:21 ]
But sin, seizing the opportunity afforded by the commandment, produced in me every kind of covetous desire. For apart from law, sin is dead.
Once I was alive apart from law; but when the commandment came, sin sprang to life and I died. Romans 7:7-9
John states: This is the verdict: Light has come into the world, but men loved darkness instead of light because their deeds were evil. John 3:19 Suppose that sin could be defined as: Seeing the light and then making the light darkness. Or try this one. Righteousness is: Seeing the light and responding as an enlightened person.
Begin with this premise and the concept of Christian perfection takes on a more accountable meaning. Begin with this premise for Jesus and you may stop making excuses for certain New Testament passages and ask: What light shined into the darkness2?
My contention: Only when Jesus is fully human can he be our example. Only as Jesus learned obedience and came to know3 can we find hope in his life and example.
1 I do not mean demean the providence of God. However, it is my belief that God “decided” before we are born to give each human being the opportunity to respond to his will. As Paul writes in Romans 2 in a reflection of Psalm 119, the creation is a witness to God that leaves no one with an excuse to turn away from God’s love and kindness.
2 Jesus is the one human being (the Word become human) who, as the light shined, never made that light darkness.
3 Luke 2:52